Bad Boy Burrito

This is a great place to get a quick burrito to-go or sit down in their patio area. The burritos are priced as you would expect for a normal burrito ($10-$15) but the quality is awesome, especially their fish and shrimp. My favorite is the Key West Shrimp Burrito. Huge burrito stuffed with fresh monster shrimp. Yum!

The OceanView Sports Pub

This sports pub (owned by a former Miami Dolphin) has great a pub style menu at fantastic prices. On top of that, they have a big outdoor bar along with seating as well as a sandy beach that sits nicely on the bay.

Bayside Gourmet

Beautifully crafted dishes for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Bayside is a favorite amongst locals for the quality of the food and the fair pricing that comes with it.

Shrimp Shack

This place was featured on Guy Fieri's Diners Drive-Ins and Dives for some of their specialty dishes. Like the name, you must get the shrimp. I like to get the Big Shrimper as it comes with four different styles of shrimp. This place has large portions with an affordable menu.

Other notables:


  • Stone Oven Pizza
  • Tower of Pizza

Pub style

  • Hog Heaven
  • Lorelei
  • Breakfast
  • Midway Cafe

Check out more delicious options here on our blog, Best Restaurants in Islamorada.

Related blog posts

Best Restaurants In Islamorada

January 25, 2022
Read More

5 Best Hotel Bars in Islamorada

January 11, 2022
Read More

Locals Guide Part Seven: Cheap Islamorada Vacation / Where to Drink

January 7, 2022
Read More